« on the other hand... | Main | Side yard: before and after »

speak your piece: to cut, or not to cut

Okay, now that my faithful readership has swelled to vast ranks (about 15), I can pose the question that was the real reason I set up this blog.

What should I do with an excess of trees in my front yard?

Having trimmed the heck out of the trees surrounding my house, I'm now wondering if I should go further and cut one or two down. Specifically, these two:

2007-08-03 housepic006 copy

The one on the right was never planted, it was just a weed that kinda took tree shape. I'm not overly fond of it, but the location is nice, on the corner of the driveway. Certainly I won't be able to replace it with a prettier tree within my nine month timeframe.

The middle one is a birch that apparently some prior owner attempted to remove...the main trunk is now a stump amidst a cluster of mini-trees. Frankly, I think it's ugly, blocks the view of the house and of my beloved acer palmatum bloodgood (Japanese maple), barely visible in the background. I also think it makes the yard look crowded and less roomy.

But...y'know...cutting down trees. TREES! Trees are our friends! Maybe I'm being too harsh on these Deciduous-Americans. Maybe house buyers like a yard full of trees!

So tell me what you think (bearing in mind the goal here is to sell the house!) To cut? Or not to cut?

2007-07-30 housepics064 2007-08-03 housepic008_edited-1

Comments (5)

Your asking the wrong guy. I have a tree farm of seedlings that came about from lack of tending. Heck, you're welcome to some if you like, including Maples, Shag bark Hickory, and some kind of pine. :-)

Ellen:

I'm a tree person myself. Also, it's a lot easier for someone to rip out a tree they don't like later than for them to replace one you rip out before they buy. :)

Hi

Personally if its an ugly tree, I say rip it out.

I think a buyer would prefer a flat smooth lawn.

.. and even if they do want a front yard full of trees a bug infested, rotting tree trunk with thin spindly sapling around it isn't really a big selling point.

Just my view.

NB. I'm a tree lover too, I just like my trees to be healthy and look good.

beth:

If you're planning to take the Acer, you'd better leave the birches...

rick:

The definition of a weed is a plant that is growing where you don't want it. The weeds have to go. The fact that the weed is a tree is irrelevant.

Post a comment

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on August 3, 2007 2:14 PM.

The previous post in this blog was on the other hand....

The next post in this blog is Side yard: before and after.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Links

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.